Journal 1 - Wilde, Aristo, and Dragons

 

7/15/2000

Son of Oscar Wilde by Vyvyan Holland

V.Holland


               Preface opens with description of visitation from his mother.

               O. Wilde named after Oscar I of Sweden.

               Good for him for standing up for his parents, especially his mother.

               Holland named his son Merlin (30)

               Holland on the confusion surrounding his date of birth, “. . . I am completely immune from the importunities of astrologer as for being able to tell them the exact hour of my birth, I cannot be certain of the exact day.” (31).

               Like his description of his childhood especially the fight of the sword cane with Cyril where he got hit in the bum.  But one wonders if Cyril would it a bit differently.

               On the money box, “This was a constant source of frustration to us until we discovered that no money-box was proof against a table-knife and a little ingenuity.” (47)

        

Constance and Cyril

       Cyril was killed by a sniper in WWI

               Hadn’t realized that the auction include the children’s toys       and his wife’s books.  Surely if it had been someone else something      could have been done.  The poor children.

               “But most disturbing of all were the telegraph poles.  Being       used to the straight orderly ones in England, the cooked French             variety filled me with terror; I saw them as live creatures, snakes         writhing out of the ground, seeking something to devour”(55).

               French governess does not at all sound pleasant.

               Like the description of going though the St. Gotland tunnel by train.

               It is always the older child who bears the weight.

               English superiority expressed “Even in those days the German people were sheep, herded and bullied by their overlords, who like sheep-dogs, marshalled them and kept them in order.  We, however, as free born Irishmen resented this regimentation and ug in out toes against it” (77)

               Description of schools in Germany in pride of the English.  But in his description of the Jesuit school, he makes at first something to be disliked but them tells of how great the teachers were.

               Think that his analysis of the name change to Holland, his mother’s family’s idea was slow to distance the family from the Oscar Wilde Scandal.

               Gives a good portrait of society and the reader seems to connect with him. 

               Seems so sad about the family, how Wilde never saw his children again.  Such a tragic waste.  His sons never got to know him except for his writings and this is a  man who is known for his fairy tales written for his sons.  Reading his fairy tales one could not know what the future would be so tragic that it happened that way.

               Would the author have been happier knowing sooner?  Don’t think so.

 

7/18/2000

Aristoto  by Chelsea Quinn Yarbro

I love this cover.


[Note- based on the life Arisoto]

               Like the reference to the beginning of the change in the painting styles on pages 26-27.  Also aristo’s dismay at the English names, especially trying to info a rhyme for Wessex.  “. . . for these English with the impossible names” (31).

               Ludovico (fantasy) on the Amazons, “Their queen, in fact, said I was almost brave enough to be a woman” (91).

               Both realms are fantasy.

               Not sure how right she got the title character, but her portrait of Margret Roper [Note- Thomas More’s daughter] seems accurate.  Particularly in response to her dedication to her father.  More himself seems to be nice, not like the man who would tell his wife that he gave her a fake jewel.  It is an interesting what if alternate history.

               I like how Yarbro defends Richard III in a way and actually makes More friendly to him.

               Like the fact that Lodovico in her novel has a good marriage.  While in La Fntasisa he struggles with romantic plot point of love for a friend’s girl.

               That the fantasy takes place in the Americas is not too clear.  Aztec Empire?  Incan?

               What the book doe is show how a person’s imagination makes them into something they want to be.  Domino’s tale would have had him as and ordinary part.  Ludovico becomes the hero his fantasy  when he achieves in killing Beni.  Indeed, Lucidcao fits into his fantasy would much better because the fantasy world operates on honor where reality operates on power.  I like the end where fantasy and reality merge, where he mixes the two in his mind.

 

7/19/2000

Dragondoomby Dennis L. McKiernan.




[Note – this is part of his Mithgar series, which draws heavily from Tolkien but has more kick ass women.  But it is a stand alone novel. Funny story, I actually first read this first in high school.  Later, when we graduated a friend gave me the first volume of the Iron Trilogy. It was only after I read  that I realized the connection to this book.  This is the best Mithgar book in my opinion.]

               Has to be one of the most tragically romantic novels ever written. Romeo and Juliet mixed with The Hobbit with the dragon taking the dwarves’ treasure and the killing of the dragon.  Almost as if McKiernan were playing a what if ending.  The book is odd for it does lack the presence of the Warrows [Note – Warrows are McKiernan’s version of Hobbits].  Like the Iron Tower Trilogy, Dragondoom is based upon Tolkien’s Middle Earth.  But McKiernan expands upon it, adding to the realm a Chinese style setting.  He merges our world and Middle Earth.

               McKiernan’s tone is always one of historian or lost letter.  He keeps to the idea of the text being found.  We care for the characters but we do not know them as well as the characters in Lord of the Rings.  This is especially true in many of the early Mithgar books.  He seem to have moved away from this as he continued to write.  But the romance here is nor forced as it was in Dragonstone.  It seems that the reader knows the characters better as in Cavern of Socrates [Note – one of McKiernan’s non Mithgar books]

 

Comments